How evidence is approved
The three evidence states, who moves a claim between them, and what a state does and does not prove.
Three states
A GL-backed value claim is in exactly one of three states. The state names are the product's; the labels are what the Value claims page shows.
| State | Label | Entered by |
|---|---|---|
| self_reported | Awaiting independent validation | The author, with Submit for validation: an AI system, a retained GL credit and a causal explanation. |
| validator_confirmed | Awaiting final attestation | A Validator who is not the author, with Validate GL evidence. |
| audit_signed_off | Final-attested | An Administrator, Governance lead or Attestor, with Final attestation. |
A claim's substantiated amount is the gross GL-backed benefit less a stated attribution reserve. The reserve is shown as its own line, never hidden in the figure.
Separation of duties
- The author cannot validate. The validate control does not appear on a claim the signed-in person authored.
- A Validator cannot final-sign. The roles that can are listed in the table above and nowhere else.
- A Contributor can author and never approve. An Auditor can read every state and change none.
- Every transition is one entry in the audit chain, with the actor, so the sequence of three people is reconstructible.
The role sets are in Who can do what, and a backend test keeps them identical to the server's.
Confidence on the Scorecard
When enabled for your organization
The Scorecard screens are switched on by Oabo for a deployment, and are off in production as of release 0.3.0.
On the Scorecard a benefit does not have a state of its own. An administrator links it to a value claim or a guided-proof claim in the same organization, and its confidence is worked out from the link each time it is read:
| Linked to | Confidence |
|---|---|
| A value claim that is Final-attested | Verified |
| A value claim that is Awaiting final attestation, or a guided-proof claim with a source on record | Measured |
| Nothing, a self-reported claim, or staff-reported hours cited beside the benefit | Estimated |
A benefit takes its best link; a use case takes its lowest benefit; the report sentence names the lowest across the month. Linking never changes an amount, and unlinking is audited like linking.
What a state does not mean
- Final-attested is an internal review status. It is not external assurance, and no Oabo state claims to be.
- No state proves causality. The causal explanation is a stated argument that a validator and an attestor accepted; it is recorded as such.
- A validated claim is not a verified system. A system's verified badge is earned by measured spend, not by a claim.
- Staff-reported hours are a statement, not a measurement. Citing them keeps a benefit Estimated, by design.